Young Citizens:
Sidebar 1

Fall 1998, v.14-3

The Child and Adolescent Statute (ECA)

 

The ECA revamps Brazil's antiquated correctional and repressive legislation and calls for a complete transformation of it's child welfare system. Helped by groups such as the Faith and Joy Foundation of Brazil (Fundaoa Fee Alegria do Brasil)--which participate at in the design of Brazil's child welfare system and maintain a high quality standard for youth services--the ECA ratifies the principles set forth by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. America's Watch, a U.S.-based non-profit organization, stated:

"Brazil enjoys some of the most progressive legislation on children's rights in the world. Its implementation, however, has been a very difficult task for the Brazilian society."

To safeguard its own enactment, the ECA mandates the creation of federal, state, and municipal councils for the rights of children and adolescents, as well as municipal guardianship councils. However, most of these municipal councils have not been equipped to effectively improve services for children of the poor. This is due to a variety of reasons:

  • In spite of a balanced distribution of government and non-government representatives in the councils, there is still a need for more active participation in the civil society.

  • City councils must have more knowledge of the ECA and wider access to information and training in order to influence positive change and adapt model programs.

  • Lack of commitment on the part of conservative forces and/or insufficient information in the senate and local governments has caused delays and hampered the implementation process.


The legal advancements brought about by the ECA represent a realistic step toward hope for all children and families in Brazil. However, progressive laws do not necessarily mean immediate improvement in the lives of children. Political action cannot end with the passage of legislation. Full enactment of the ECA will be made possible only by a strong commitment of all sectors of society. As UNICEF points out,

"Any effort to promote children's rights should strive for broad public awareness and debate. Once the general public is concerned about children's rights, political leaders understand the importance of giving them priority."

 
   
  NEW DESIGNS FOR YOUTH DEVELOPMENT © 1998